Ai Yori Aoshi Books 1 & 2

I thought I’d enjoy this story of a young couple coping with the fallout from an arranged marriage, but I found the male-focused nudity distracting. Kaoru was the heir to an important family business, but an incident with his mother led to him leaving the family and going to college in Tokyo. Aoi was his promised bride since they were kids together. She’s grown into a traditional, naive young woman who’s now come to marry him.

This sounded vaguely Romeo and Juliet-like romantic, where a couple has to fight their families for their love. Except… for a story about formality, we see Aoi naked more than I thought was necessary. Although she’s supposedly concerned with tradition, she has no problem climbing into Kaoru’s bed their first night together, pressing his face into her breasts, or snuggling naked with him when he’s sick. There are also several fantasy sequences of her in the bath.

Ai Yori Aoshi Book 1 cover
Ai Yori Aoshi Book 1
Buy this book

This was originally serialized in a magazine aimed at young men, so I don’t find it surprising, but it’s also not for me. I should have guessed I wasn’t the target audience from the cover, a teasing image of Aoi wearing an open shirt with visibly prominent nipples. I do like her as a character, so I gave it another try. Unfortunately, in book two, things are even more exaggerated than in the first book.

Two new female characters are introduced to provide more nudity options. Tina is a free-spirited American who wears tight and skimpy clothing, and Taeko is defined only by her shyness and her huge breasts.

Ai Yori Aoshi Book 2 cover
Ai Yori Aoshi Book 2
Buy this book

At times, I found myself thinking that Aoi had wandered in from some other story. Her guardian, Miyabi, and the two new women, are perfect for a sex comedy, with touchy-feely accidents resulting in them sitting on Kaoru or grabbing each other’s breasts or ending up in drunken misunderstandings. I missed the air of sweet romance that Aoi and Kaoru were moving towards in the first volume and the conflict between class expectations and the desires of the heart.

All the women and Kaoru wind up living together in one big house with Aoi as landlady. With that premise, and their vacation bath, and their attempt to set up a club teahouse, I was reminded of Love Hina‘s fanservice. Sometimes, this story isn’t even good titillation — one woman’s breasts noticeably and excessively change size between the medium shot and the nude close-up — but I suppose the audience doesn’t really mind.

4 Comments

  1. Ed Sizemore

    Johanna, I haven’t read the books but I did see the anime of this series. When the story focuses on the relationship between Karou and Aoi it is sweet without being saccharine or sappy. It is very touching to watch as Karou comes to fall in love with Aoi. They have a lot hurdles with both families to overcome. I wanted to cut out all the nonsense and just stick to the real heart of the series. I think all the extra gets added because the audience was originally young boys/men and such an emotionally honest and intense look at love and the traditional problems found in Japanese families would have been hard for most to handle. I wish author would have considered writing for an older audience.

  2. Yeah, this could have been a really interesting story without all the sexist art. Just like All-Star Batman and Robin, the Boy Wonder or Birds of Prey. (hee hee)

  3. I actually read those two and I loved it! I loved the art ^///^ lol it was the best i fell in love with it as soon as i started reading it but you know everyone has their own taste

  4. [...] I hear the term “harem manga”, I think of one of those series where a goofy guy has his pick of zaftig girls. I’d never seen the opposite — [...]

Leave a Reply

Comments are closed.