Nodame Cantabile Book 1
- Posted by Johanna on January 20, 2006 at 9:57 am
- Category: Manga Reviews
- CREDITS: by Tomoko Ninomiya; adaptation by David and Eriko Walsh
- PUBLISHER: Del Rey, $10.95 US
Although containing more subtly-drawn characters than many manga series, Nodame Cantabile left no significant impression on me after reading.
Shinichi wants to be a conductor, but he’s currently studying piano to improve his overall skills. (He also turns out to be quite the violin virtuoso when the plot demands.) Nodame is the girl next door, an untrained piano genius with a pigsty of an apartment. She’s driven by appetite, stealing other people’s lunches and loyal to whichever boy gives her dinner.
In pages thick with background tones, Shinichi’s purpose is reaffirmed through taking care of Nodame. His discipline and her talent together will overcome her sloppiness to produce great music. The conflict between technical proficiency and playing with emotion creates a tension that I suspect will be more resonant to the Japanese reader than the American.
The subject matter is immensely difficult to pull off on the printed page, since music can’t be conveyed through a silent medium. As a result, we have to rely in many cases on the words of one character praising another’s skills on piano or violin. It has to be about telling, not showing, which pushes the reader further away from involvement.
January 20, 2006 at 10:06 am
Interesting. I haven’t yet read this, although it’s sitting on my bookshelf waiting for me.
I recall many years ago, Dave Sim (before he went completely nuts) discussing why there was dancing in Cerebus, but never any musicians. His rationale was much the same, indicating that any attempt to portray music in a soundless medium just wouldn’t work.
I contrast that with something like Scott Pilgrim, where I think that Brian O’Malley effectively conveys rock band performances. Or Para Para, with Andy Seto bringing musical theatre to life on the page.
But then, rock ‘n’ roll & musical theatre are as much about the physical performance as the musical, whereas in most cases classical music is much more about the music than the performers.
January 20, 2006 at 10:22 am
I’d agree — I think O’Malley does a great job capturing energy, but that’s different from music.
I remember Megan Kelso doing a piece in Queen of the Black Black that beautifully captured reactions to music, but I still had no idea what the music sounded like, only what emotions it raised in the listeners.
February 2, 2006 at 1:21 am
i wonder who’s the main character, nodame or shinichi? if the last, the title should be change into “shinichi’s cantabile”.all in all, it’s worth reading comic
September 23, 2006 at 8:43 am
[…] I’m going to try LA CORDA d’ORO, because the music setting sounds intriguing. It didn’t work for me with Nodame Cantabile because those characters got too weird and unbelievable, so maybe this will fit my tastes better. […]
January 5, 2007 at 3:14 pm
I suppose that musicians are the ideal readers. If you don’t get the music through paper it only makes sense to educate your senses. It’s a step up that most people aren’t capable of. The character’s are amusing although unnecessarily silly at times. But the whole gist about truly loving music and its essense can only be appreciated by the true music lover. Though the art is simple one should not have such high expectations for music (especially classical) to escape the pages to an uneducated reader.
June 28, 2007 at 10:04 pm
[…] Nodame Cantabile — As David suggests, I’m not listing books where I sampled a first volume and didn’t care for it, because that’s outside the scope of this exercise. I mention this one only because I tried it twice, again after reader encouragement, and it’s just not for me. The pigsty lifestyle of the lead put me off. […]
October 9, 2007 at 7:22 am
[…] by Tomoko Ninomiya Publisher description Previous review of Book 1 […]
January 17, 2008 at 10:22 pm
i love this series a lot. Well i think this have to do for my love for music as well =)
March 6, 2008 at 8:31 am
[…] to me that I’m forgetting some. Does Del Rey have any women-targeted manga? Update: Yes. Nodame Cantabile is considered […]