Sorcerers & Secretaries Book 2

The short series concludes in this second volume. (I previously recommended the first book.)

As it opens, Nicole has told Josh that she doesn’t want to see him any more, choosing the perceived demands of her writing over real-life friendships. She quickly learns better, that relationships help your art instead of getting in its way.

Sorcerers & Secretaries Book 2 cover
Sorcerers & Secretaries Book 2
Buy this book

Josh, demonstrating unexpected depth for someone previously chasing girls just because he could get them easily, doesn’t let her get away without explaining herself. Once he understands, he immediately gives her appreciation and support. He even suggests something for her to work for: a magazine is having a fiction contest, and he wants to help her submit her story. He loves her creativity and wants to learn more about the world she’s building. (It’s a shame that the story-within-the-story, a generic fantasy quest, doesn’t live up to his praise of it.)

Given that these books exist because of Ganter’s discovery through one of Tokyopop’s Rising Stars of Manga contests, the boundary between fiction and autobiography is a bit thin. The characters also have a tendency to tell each other plot events and their motivations in blatant fashion, working in predictable steps towards the eventual happy ending.

In order to pad out the book, there’s a second story that should be a welcome distraction but is even more formulaic. Nicole’s co-worker Susan and Josh’s roommate William have met and begun dating. While Josh and Nicole are friends, and they’re growing to appreciate each other through their tentative honesty, Susan and William have the opposite kind of relationship. They’re playing games, attempting to manipulate each other into getting only what they want, building on sexual attraction instead of knowing anything about who the other person is.

It’s a traditional romance-novel view of male-female interaction, one where the boy has to be tricked into realizing that one committed partner is better than the smorgasbord of sex he’s been wallowing in. There’s a big fight, and it’s not until he thinks he’s lost her that he realizes he really cares for her.

Taken together, the two threads are at best a comfortable read. Who’s against an artist making her first creative breakthrough or couples falling in love? However, the whole thing is presented in two dimensions, missing that special something that provides depth and a reason for readers to invest themselves. Turn the crank, move the pieces, now they need to be here so the threads tie up and everyone gets what they want (or no longer wants it, in the case of Mom’s about-face on her dreams for her daughter).

I had such hopes for this conclusion after really enjoying the first book, but I was disappointed in the feeling that the author didn’t have to stretch for anything, that she took the easy way of making everything work out just hunky-dory. It makes the story forgettable instead of praiseworthy, in my opinion.


7 Responses to “Sorcerers & Secretaries Book 2”

  1. Sebastian Says:

    Two things…

    One: personally, I didn’t have an equally negative impression of the book. Perhaps because I haven’t read enough romance-novels to find the plot as generic and I really, really liked the graphic style. It was very neatly wrapped up, though, perhaps a bit too neatly.

    Two: Ganter being “discovered” through Tokyopop feels a bit skewed. She was published through (late) Studio Ironcat’s (late) “AmeriManga” anthology about 1-2 years before she entered the RSoM contest and she had her webcomic “Reman Mythology” even before that, IIRC. All that, of course, wasn’t nearly as widely distributed as TP is.

  2. Johanna Says:

    I was concerned that my comments may have come out more negative than I intended, probably because of my disappointment. I was so looking forward to reading this! And the experience was not nearly as good as I expected. It’s not a bad book, just not a great one, either.

    Good point on her creative history. Thank you for correcting me.

  3. MangaBlog » Blog Archive » Happy 801 day! Says:

    [...] At Okazu, Erica Friedman reviews the classic yuri manga Claudine. Johanna Draper Carlson finds vol. 2 of Sorcerers and Secretaries doesn’t quite meet her expectations at Comics Worth Reading. At the BasuGasuBakuhatsu Anime [...]

  4. Journalista - the news weblog of The Comics Journal » Blog Archive » Aug. 1, 2007: Pleasant Dullsville summer Says:

    [...] Johanna Draper Carlson reviews the second volume of Amy Kim Ganter’s Sorcerers and Secretaries. [...]

  5. Rena Says:

    I, too, felt the same way–that the second book didn’t meet the expectations that had been set up by the first. The “other” relationship in the second book only served as a mediocre distraction from the two existing storylines (Nicole/Josh’s relationship and the fantasy story). I really could have done without it.

    While overall, it wasn’t everything I hoped it would be, it was still better than a lot of other stuff I’ve read. And the art is a nice change-up from the usual manga fare.

  6. Lea Says:

    I hope this is apropriate, given that the review is about the contents of the book, but dang that cover is cute!

    Amy’s also done the illustrations for the game Diner Dash. I don’t know if she’s done the sequels as well (if she’s not, it’s someone doing a good imitation).

    I’m glad Sebastian cleared up Amy’s cv. Amy was one of the artists I tried to hire for GirlAMatic when I was recruiting before its initial launch.

  7. Tokyopop OEL — Able to Create a Satisfying Ending? » Comics Worth Reading Says:

    [...] book was one of my top ten reads of 2006 due to its charming blend of fantasy and romance. The second book I couldn’t even recommend, because of its change in tone, its unrealistic instant solution to [...]




Categories:

Pages:



Meta:

Most Recent Posts: