Hellboy: The Troll Witch and Others

Hellboy: The Troll Witch and Others is the best collection out there for understanding the appeal of the title character and his series. Hellboy gets things done by being tougher than the other monster. Rather like the original James Bond, it’s not that he’s smarter than his foe (he’s often not, when facing off against mad scientists) or stronger; he’s just more determined, and he can take a lot of punishment. Hellboy runs into, or is sent to find, the beasties responsible for odd happenings, and then they fight, until Hellboy wins.

Hellboy: The Troll Witch and Others cover
Hellboy: The Troll Witch and Others
Buy this book

The appeal of these stories are twofold, both due to author Mike Mignola: his distinctive artistic vision, and his love of creepy and odd folklore from around the world. The latter leads to freshness and creativity in Hellboy’s foes and fights. In the first story, originally published in a Wizard promo, Hellboy encounters a kind of Malaysian vampiress with a detachable head. (This is explained in the author’s note, one of which accompanies each story, a very valuable addition.)

Other stories included here previously appeared in the “Dark Horse Book of” anthologies — Monsters, the Dead, Witchcraft, and Hauntings. Hellboy fights a Hydra (accompanied by a mysterious little girl charmingly inspired by Mignola’s daughter), a vampire gambler, a haunted house, all the usual odd kinds of threats.

It’s not all about the fighting, though. In a change of pace, the title story features Hellboy listening to an old woman’s tales, inspired by Norwegian folklore. It nods at the way different versions of stories have different purposes and at alternate ways of solving problems other than punching. There’s also an experiment, a story where the dialogue of “The Ghoul” is made up of quotes from poetry.

As for the art, well, if you’ve ever seen Mignola’s craggy, blocky figures, you’ll recognize it. He specializes in dark, murky, ancient, menacing, suggesting years of secret plots and disturbing creatures awoken. Hellboy’s design, with that giant, rocky fist and an air of timeless weariness, perfectly encapsulates it.

It was also enlightening to see Mignola’s world drawn by other artists. “The Vampire of Prague”, new to this collection, is illustrated by P. Craig Russell. It has more of the delicacy associated with his style, although Hellboy is still appropriately lumpy. The second half of the book reprints “Makoma”, an African creation folktale drawn by Richard Corben that’s impressive in its scope. It’s structured as a typical quest story, in which Hellboy defeats ever-more-powerful enemies (who then become a kind of portable chorus-in-a-bag) until he reaches his reward at the end of the world.

Overall, it’s a terrific sampler with a range of stories demonstrating Mignola’s interests and creative sparks.

3 Responses to “Hellboy: The Troll Witch and Others”

  1. Batman: Gotham Knight » Comics Worth Reading Says:

    […] it’s Mignola’s art brought to life. In fact, the sewer scenes are closer to the style of the Hellboy comics than the Hellboy cartoons are. In this vignette, Batman has to rescue Cardinal O’Fallon from […]

  2. Ed’s MoCCA Comics » Comics Worth Reading Says:

    […] published by Blacklist Studios The art and feel of the book is very similar to Mignola’s Hellboy. I’m a huge fan of Hellboy, so I’m already predisposed to like this book. The first […]

  3. January 2012 Previews: Recommendations, Reminders, and Ramblings » Comics Worth Reading Says:

    […] concept (a greatly overplayed category in comics these days, and one that I now sadly lump the Hellboy/BPRD franchise into) — but they’re worth watching for what I think of as their rescue […]




Most Recent Posts: