Popeye the Sailor 1938-1940 Volume 2
June 17, 2008

Review by KC Carlson

Well, blow me down! This is great stuff!

Although I’ve loved animation all of my life, somehow I let Popeye slip to the background in my frantic desire to learn all that I could about about the Warner Bros. characters (Daffy Duck is an important role model for me) and the people who brought them to life. Of course, I watched Popeye as a youngster. How could I not? He was everywhere in the kid-friendly TV world of the 1960s. But somewhere along the line I forgot about him…

Popeye the Sailor 1938-1940 Volume 2 cover
Popeye the Sailor 1938-1940 Volume 2
Buy this DVD

… or so I thought. Darned if I didn’t remember every single moment of most of the cartoons on this new DVD collection! Okay, maybe I missed a bit of Popeye’s famous mutterings. Or maybe I just understood more of it as an (alleged) adult…. But every single storyline, every one of Olive Oyl’s bizarre poses, every bit of music, every cliffhanger, and every can of spinach all came back to me in a flood of happy childhood memories. Thanks for the gumball, Popeye!

Popeye the Sailor 1938-1940 Volume 2 is exactly what it says it is — a chronological collection of all the Popeye cartoons produced by the Fleischer Studios from 1938 (beginning with “I Yam Love Sick” — the previous 1938 cartoons were on Volume 1) through 1940. All of the cartoons have been completely remastered and are in glorious black and white, with the exception of “Aladdin and His Wonderful Lamp,” the acclaimed two-reel Technicolor spectacular, which completes the Popeye Technicolor Trilogy.

Volume 2 comes in a sleek, stripped-down 2-DVD set, with 31 complete Popeye cartoons and a wealth of special features. The Volume 1 set was issued last year as a massive 4-DVD box set, which I originally passed up due to a mini-flood of great animation projects all released within a relatively short time, overwhelming my budget for DVDs. I like this new 2-DVD format over the big box for two reasons: monetarily, it’s easier on the wallet, and aesthetically, the smaller number of cartoons — especially with this single-character, many variations on a limited theme series — is much easier to mentally digest. It also doesn’t hurt that the smaller sets are on a fairly quick-release pattern — Volume 3 is scheduled for late September!

Popeye the Sailor 1933-1938 Volume 1 cover
Popeye the Sailor 1933-1938 Volume 1
Buy this book

There’s a really high percentage of great cartoons on this set, beginning with the aforementioned “Aladdin and His Wonderful Lamp,” a 16-minute tour-de-force of Disney-quality animation. It also features one of my favorite bits of Popeye mutterings: “I’ve never made love in Technicolor before!” Also included is the under-appreciated “Shakespearian Spinach,” where Popeye replaces ham actor Bluto in an operatic version of Romeo and Juliet (Olive Oyl), where the three characters sing the entire cartoon. Oh, and Popeye ends up in drag in an attempt to fool Bluto, predating Bugs Bunny and Elmer Fudd in “What’s Opera, Doc?” by almost 20 years. Bluto in this cartoon was voiced by Pinto Colvig, better known as the voice of Goofy in the Disney cartoons, which just adds to the general strangeness.

There are also first appearances of some of the regular supporting characters. Poopdeck Pappy, Popeye’s 99-year old father (“I hates relatives!”) is introduced in the bizarre and surreal “Goonland,” which you’ve probably guessed, also stars the Goons. Pappy also appears in two other cartoons in this set. Pipeye, Pupeye, Poopeye, and Peepeye pop up in a dream sequence as the children of Popeye and Olive in “Wimmen is a Myskery.” In later cartoons, the foursome are presented as Popeye’s four identical nephews (And how does that happen?). And Eugene the magical Jeep is introduced in “The Jeep,” one of my favorite Popeye cartoons. The scene where The Jeep serenely levitates up several flights of stairs while Popeye frantically scrambles up the stairs trying to catch up to him, is almost zen-like. The Jeep’s musical theme has been gently playing in my head for the last several days.

There are special features a’plenty on this set. There are over a dozen commentaries for individual cartoons, all by noted animation historians and filmmakers such as Jerry Beck, Greg Ford, Paul Dini, and Michael Barrier. There’s an informative documentary about the animation studio entitled, “Out of the Inkwell: The Fleischer Story,” as well as “Popumentaries” on Poopdeck Pappy, The Jeep, Mae Questel and the voices of Olive Oyl. “Men of Spinach and Steel” is a great examination of who was the first super-powered character: Popeye or Superman? (Both were animated by the Fleischers.) Plus there’s a vintage short on the making of “Aladdin and His Wonderful Lamp,” a complete Superman cartoon, rare pencil tests and storyboards, and a couple of audio-only features, one an interview with Jack Mercer, the voice of Popeye.

Popeye the Sailor 1938-1940 Volume 2 is a lovingly assembled tribute to one of the classic American icons, a character so beloved that he even eclipsed Mickey Mouse’s popularity for part of the 1930s. And you can see why in the cartoons in this collection. I am so out the door looking for Volume 1, just as soon as I stop kicking myself for missing it!

(A complimentary copy for this review was provided by the publisher.)

12 Responses  
Ed Sizemore writes:  


What always impressed me about the Technicolor Fleischer cartoons is their sense of scenery depth. No one came close to building the layers of backgrounds that they did. Even Disney at its prime couldn’t duplicate the effect.

They really were the perfect studio for Popeye. They weren’t scared to be risque or absurd. Both qualities are essential to the character.

Alan Coil writes:  

As noted at both ComicMix and by Mark Evanier, this is great stuff, and not to be missed, but buyer beware that there is a Popeye and Friends collection, too, that features the mundane ‘toon from the late 70s/early 80s. Don’t let yourself get confused.

These old Popeye cartoons are what made me a lifelong fan of Popeye. I prefer my spinach raw, however.

Bill D. writes:  

I was watching a later, clipped version of the Aladdin cartoon (one with obviously animated later framing sequences of Popeye and Olive at the movie theater) on Boomerang the other day with my son, and I was pleasantly reminded that that cartoon contains one of my all-time favorite ‘toon gag lines: as footman for the newly royal Aladdin departs after bringing gifts for Princess Olive, he bows and says “Salami, Salami, Boloney.” Maybe less than sensitive in today’s climate, but it still makes me laugh every time.

Roger A writes:  

Ed – One of the reasons for the extra depth in the Technicolor Popeye’s is that sections of them were filmed against constructed sets that were often built on a turntable. It’s a technique that fascinated me as a kid and I still find it impressive.

KC – Great review. You made me want to spend money.

Barney writes:  

There’s news on the Termite Terrace Trading Post that WB is going to be offering replacements for the first disc due to two of the cartoons not having their original titles: http://forums.goldenagecartoons.com/showthread.php?t=11407

Johanna writes:  

Thanks! I just called, and they told me that they would be shipping out replacement discs after they receive them in 8-10 weeks.

KC writes:  

Ed & Roger: While still gorgeous, “Aladdin” didn’t really go to town with the layered backgrounds like they did in the first two extravaganzas, which is why I didn’t emphasize it here. Those two cartoons are on Vol. 1. And thanks for giving me the chance to point that out!

Alan: Good point. Thanks!

Bill: That IS a great line! I also loved Olive’s “Help, Popeye! – Oh, I mean Aladdin!” while she’s being captured.

Ed Sizemore writes:  


Thanks for the info. Very cool.

September Warner DVDs » Comics Worth Reading writes:  

[…] And then, at the end of the month come the cartoons, with the Peanuts Holiday Collection on the 23rd — it includes It’s a Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown, A Charlie Brown Thanksgiving, and A Charlie Brown Christmas, the three big holidays — and the next Popeye box set, Volume 3, on September 30. That’s a must-have after how much KC enjoyed the previous one. […]

Popeye the Sailor 1941-1943 Volume 3 » Comics Worth Reading writes:  

[…] cartoons to boot, Popeye Vol. 3: 1941-1943 is a strangely fun addition to this should-not-miss classic animation series! And next time, the color Popeye cartoons […]

Peanuts: Deluxe Holiday Collection » Comics Worth Reading writes:  

[…] over the years — are assembled with the same care that Warners extends to its Warner Bros., Popeye, Hanna-Barbara, and DC Comics animation packages. The picture and sound quality is fantastic! I […]

Max Fleischer’s Superman 1941-1942 » Comics Worth Reading writes:  

[…] like Bugs Bunny, were still a few years from breaking out to the big time). The Fleischers’ Popeye was the most popular character for a couple of years (beating even Mickey Mouse), and the […]


»  Substance: WordPress   »  Style: Ahren Ahimsa
Copyright 2009-2015 Johanna Draper Carlson