Sgt. Frog Book 18

Sgt. Frog Book 18 cover
Sgt. Frog Book 18
Buy this book

I haven’t read a Sgt. Frog book since 2006, when I gave up after volume 12. At that point, I’d grown tired of the series, finding its comedy repetitive. Yet I was glad to get a chance to check in with it again, because I remember liking it in the early days, and with so much time passed, I was sure it’d be fresh again.

After a pointless flashback about super-rich Momoka comes the kinds of stories I remember. The frog aliens decide to become mosquitoes because they are so annoying to humans. Military training at the beach means excuses for girls in bikinis. Frog paint has special characteristics. (The most creative story, it’s also one of the shortest, unfortunately, so it feels like filler.) The boy wishes to go to the moon to get work done in peace, so the frogs build a lunar hotel.

Unfortunately, I wasn’t laughing. The frogs no longer seem to have separate personalities, or the distinctions are shown so subtly that I missed them. And the stories weren’t as funny as I remembered… or three years wasn’t enough time for them to seem fresh again. I gave up on the book halfway through because I was just turning pages wishing for the end to arrive. I guess you can’t go back again. (The publisher provided a review copy.)

6 Comments

  1. […] One Wish (Manga Maniac Cafe) Susan S. on vol. 1 of Raiders (Manga Jouhou) Johanna Draper Carlson on vol. 18 of Sgt. Frog (Comics Worth Reading) Julie on vol. 6 of Shaman Warrior (Manga Maniac Cafe) Connie on vol. 21 of […]

  2. Couldn’t even finish it? Ouch. Then again, I guess I’d given up on the series in my own way since I wasn’t even aware there was a new volume out.

    Maybe this will have to be a library read for me.

    Did Tokyopop improve the paper quality? The last volume had really thin paper, which was especially annoying given the price had just gone up a buck.

  3. I may have given up on it quickly, but I’m a little impatient these days, since I’m trying to clear the decks for the new year. I didn’t notice anything about the paper quality one way or another, which suggests that it was at least acceptable.

  4. I’m finding myself more impatient these days as well. Part of it might be that I’m doing most of my reading via the library so there’s no loss if I don’t finish (or even start) something I checked out.

  5. […] is running a contest where you can win copies of Sgt. Frog Book 18, the anime DVDs, various pins, wallets, and other tchotkes, or GIANT CARDBOARD FROG […]

  6. […] the dealer’s room to look for one or more of the series. Here are the 12 series they discussed: Sgt. Frog, Karakuri Odette, Dazzle, Beck: Mongolian Chop Squad, Gundam: Ecole du Ciel, X-Day, Planetes, […]

Leave a Reply

Comments are closed.