Arrow: The Complete First Season
September 30, 2013

Fans of the comic know the backstory, although it takes on new immediacy seeing it on TV. Young billionaire Oliver Queen (Stephen Amell) has been shipwrecked on a deserted island for five years. After he’s rescued, with the skills he learned to survive, he’s determined to bring justice to Starling City to make up for his father’s corruption. He roams the streets as a mysterious hooded vigilante, taking down criminals among the rich 1% (making for a timely undercurrent, that of the privileged receiving overdue punishment).

In the comics, his experience was just a way to explain how he got so good with a bow and arrow. On TV, he’s more of a tortured hero: early on, his doctor says 20% of his body is covered in scar tissue and he had 12 fractures that didn’t properly heal. The scars are often visible, since the show isn’t shy about showing off its hero’s good looks and body. (OMG those training scenes!) He’s also been affected mentally, as one would expect from surviving such desperate circumstances and returning to a family who thought he was dead.

Speedy is now Oliver’s younger sister Thea (Willa Holland), while Laurel Drake (Katie Cassidy) is an enemy, a legal aid attorney who hates Oliver because her sister died in the shipwreck (plus, they used to date). Oliver’s accompanied by John Diggle (David Ramsey), bodyguard; the two men come to grudging respect as the show progresses. Diggle is a very necessary (and original) character in grounding the hero and providing support, assistance, and a voice of reason. Later, they’re joined by Felicity (Emily Bett Rickards), a techie whose mouth often runs away with her.

I hadn’t tried the series before, but I wish I had, since I liked it a lot more than I expected to. I was going by Smallville, the other CW young superhero show, which I never cared much about. This has more depth, although there are plenty of action scenes. Unlike Smallville‘s “monster of the week”, this show tends to have “bad businessman of the week”, livened up by various costumed guest appearances, whether Deathstroke or the Huntress. Or John Barrowman playing another corrupt businessman dad!

As the series progresses, we learn more about what happened to Oliver on the island (which is much more complex than one might imagine) and the conspiracies affecting his family. It took a while for the island scenes to grow on me — at first, I feared we were in for a Lost situation. (I liked the crack about it made in the first episode.) I also didn’t like the “outrunning bullets” scenes in the pilot, since there’s heroic, and there’s unbelievable.

Watching this series in giant lumps emphasizes the ways the character interactions change as events progress. Things get particularly tricky when Laurel’s father, a police detective, arrests Oliver for being a vigilante, and Laurel agrees to defend him (episode 5). I do wish the producers didn’t buy into the idea that heroes have to have no personal connections, from fear that the people he cares about might be used against him. (The producers have noted how much they’re inspired by Christopher Nolan’s Batman trilogy, which has a similar approach.) I fear that’s going to continue to be used for soap opera-style complications (a staple of pretty people CW shows), although I admit, I enjoy the twists, particularly when his little sister hits on his friend.

Arrow: The Complete First Season on Blu-ray comes with both DVDs and Blu-ray copies of the show (nine discs total, making for a chunky package), plus access to the 23 episodes on UltraViolet. I’ve only watched six so far, so I have a lot to go, and I’m looking forward to diving into them.

The special features are mostly deleted scenes, with almost half the episodes having at least one. There’s also a half-hour “Arrow Comes Alive!”, a self-congratulatory talking-heads piece where the producers describe their character choices and talk about why they were good ones. “Arrow: Fight School/Stunt School” is 19 minutes about filming the action scenes. The 28-minute “Arrow at PaleyFest 2013″ introduces the show, its cast, and the producers, moderated by Geoff Johns. There’s also a 2 1/2-minute gag reel.

I would have liked to have seen a piece about the comic history, but I suppose it’s not particularly relevant to what they’re doing here, which is reinventing the character in a way that makes sense to today’s viewers and what they want from a superhero series. At that, they’re successful. (The studio provided a review copy.)

10 Responses  
Steely Dan writes:  

I was pleasantly surprised by how much I liked this series. My main gripes are that the soap opera aspect is laid on a little thick, and (like most American TV series) there were too many episodes in the first season (if it were 10 or even 13 episodes its storytelling would have been much tighter, much more lean). That said, I’m really impressed by the style and complexity of the action sequences (especially on a TV budget). And I also liked how they were able to bring in so many elements from Mike Grell’s “The Longbow Hunters” (the only Green Arrow series I’ve ever really liked) yet still make it feel so contemporary.

James Schee writes:  

I was really impressed by this series. This is a character that in comics either seemed dated and at times creepy (Pre-52) and just missing something post 52. Yet in live action it just works, especially with his really impressive supporting cast.

Like you I feared another Smallville, which except for a few episodes I found mostly unwatchable. Yet not the case here at all. I do wonder how they’ll handle the Flash series that’ll spin out of it, but have a bit of faith given what they did in one season here.

Joel R writes:  

I would really like to see you revisit the review when you’ve finished all the episodes. I really liked Arrow. I was a big fan of Green Arrow in the comics. From Grell’s Longbow Hunters, to Kevin Smith’s revival, followed by Meltzer and Winick. I have been very happy with Arrow so far. I thought the first Season was an excellent, slow burn, origin story. The final episode of Arrow season 1 is an epic bookend to the season. I’m very excited to see where season 2 goes especially with the Flash series, cautiously optimistic on that one.

Johanna writes:  

I do hope to come back to it — it’ll be at least a week or two before I have time for another viewing binge, though. It’s reminding me how much I enjoyed discovering the Longbow Hunters and the Black Canary series back when.

Jim Perreault writes:  

I enjoyed the first season of Arrow, but I did feel that it dragged towards the end. Especially with the island plot line. It felt like they had to stretch it so that it climaxed at the same time as the other plot threads.

But they did some really innovative things with the characters. With the notable exception of the Huntress, who became very one-dimensional in her 2nd appearance.

No Amazon Wonder Woman TV Show Coming » DVDs Worth Watching writes:  

[…] already running Arrow (which is fun and successful) and planning a Flash spinoff as well as putting Hourman and iZombie […]

Watch Cliff Chiang Draw and Some Thoughts on DC All Access » Comics Worth Reading writes:  

[…] play along on Twitter before Monday morning.) The earlier content featured a visit to the set of Arrow, promoting the “Suicide Squad” episode that aired Wednesday. (This video came out […]

Wizard World Chicago Guests Include Matt Smith, William Shatner, and Of Course Stan Lee » Comics Worth Reading writes:  

[…] also this summer’s Guardians of the Galaxy), David Boreanaz (Bones, Angel), Katie Cassidy (Arrow), Norman Reedus (The Walking Dead), William Shatner (come on…), a number of other Star Trek […]

Arrow Season 2 Comes to DVD » DVDs Worth Watching writes:  

[…] found the first season a pleasant surprise. I haven’t been as big a fan of the second, primarily due to not loving […]

Arrow: The Complete Second Season » DVDs Worth Watching writes:  

[…] found the first season of Arrow a pleasant surprise. I hadn’t tried it on the CW, but I discovered it on disc, and watching […]


»  Substance: WordPress   »  Style: Ahren Ahimsa
Copyright 2009-2015 Johanna Draper Carlson