Comic Book Clubs (TCAF Panel)

TCAF 2018 poster

At the 2018 Toronto Comic Arts Festival (TCAF), I had the pleasure of attending a panel on “How to Launch a Comic Book Club”. I am part of a comic club in Madison, Wisconsin, so I was curious to see how this was similar and different.

Led by Philippe Leblanc, the panel was more of a discussion group, which I appreciated. It was informative hearing the questions others had as well as Leblanc’s suggestions. Unfortunately, co-moderator Helen Anderson, who hosts the Ottawa Comic Book Club with Leblanc, was unable to attend.

The Ottawa Comic Book Club is officially sponsored by their library, but before that connection was made, they searched for an appropriate place in which to meet. That was Leblanc’s first point: Location is key. He told a memorable story about the various places they’d tried earlier, including a bar. That seemed like a good choice, since food and drink added to the discussion atmosphere, until they wound up having a meeting during a hockey playoff the club was unaware of while everyone else in the bar was participating loudly.

(The club I attend also meets at the local library, but we aren’t officially sponsored. We’re just allowed to reserve meeting rooms as part of the library audience. This may be a difference between Canada and the U.S.)

TCAF 2018 poster

A library is an excellent choice, since they’re usually centrally located, the space can be available for free, and they provide options for people to participate without having to buy comics. That leads into the second key point, selection of material.

The Ottawa club works like a traditional book club, where everyone reads and discusses the same book each month. That means works need to be selected that are in print and relatively easy to find. Leblanc also suggested not picking works that everyone’s already got an opinion on, since that tends to depress discussion. Ages also need to be taken into account. If your club is open to both teens and adults, the younger age range may restrict some choices.

A local comic shop may be interested in supporting the club. Some have space that could be used for the meeting, but if not, they may also be interested in providing discounts on the books selected for discussion in return for promotion.

I would add that it’s a better choice to select stand-alone reads, graphic novels instead of serialized comics, both because they’re more readily available and because they can be more easily discussed as a single unit, without requiring additional knowledge or reading.

As the Ottawa club became more established, they began inviting authors, artists, and other contributors to participate in meetings, either in person or via screen. Some of the choices Leblanc mentioned having read in the club weren’t particularly popular or well-known (particularly outside of Canada), but they were selected because of the creator being available or interested in meeting with the club.

Another option is what my club does. We don’t prescribe a particular title; instead, we talk about what we’ve read over the past month that we enjoyed or would recommend or just want to talk about. (Sometimes it’s cathartic explaining why something didn’t work for you.)

We also share and lend out our reads, if we can, so a particular book may end up being read by a number of members, leading to continuing discussion over a period of months. I’ve often been enlightened hearing what someone appreciated about a book I didn’t care for, or vice versa, as different readers appreciate different elements.

Because of our format, we don’t have a traditional moderator, but a more organized club will want someone to fill that role. It can be the club organizer, or the responsibility could rotate among interested members. It doesn’t require much effort, but someone should prepare a few questions to start discussion, make sure everyone feels comfortable participating (encouraging the quiet and controlling the rowdy), and handle reminders of when the next meeting is. Sending out notes for those who couldn’t attend is also a nice feature.

As members of my club have come and gone (we’re in a university town, so a certain proportion of members are students), we’ve tweaked our format to serve the interests of who’s participating, while welcoming new ideas. Options we’ve tried include

  • craft sessions — one member is a professional inker, and she presented on how that’s done with some practice art for us all to try
  • historical information — I put together way too many slides explaining the Legion of Super-Heroes when some members, watching Supergirl, didn’t know much about the team
  • practice presentations — a member was getting her paper ready for an academic conference, and we were a test audience

It’s a great feeling to meet regularly with other comic fans and learn from their interests and observations. If you’re curious to see how it goes, put the word out and give it a try! (Originally posted at Good Comics for Kids.)


  • David Oakes

    Unless you had more slides than Legion members, you can’t have too many.

    Also nice to hear that you lend. That is the best basis for a club. (I mean, if you can’t get an inverted rocketship…)

  • I was once part of a local comic book club. I had no hand in organizing it, but we used a big box bookstore that had a meeting room space that was open to the public. People would get together and talk about/review what comics they read over the past month. Occasionally we had other people who would educate us on stuff. We had a former employee of a major auction house show us CGC comics and talk about high grade comics as investments. Others told us about their time working for a now closed comics distribution company. Eventually it was the same people always showing up talking about the same stuff and we started meeting less, but some of us were still seeing other as friends (movie night) and going to conventions together.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *