Orange Planet Book 1 and Male Harem Manga

When I hear the term “harem manga”, I think of one of those series where a goofy guy has his pick of zaftig girls. I’d never seen the opposite — but I may just not have been looking hard enough.

Orange Planet Book 1 cover
Orange Planet Book 1
Buy this book

It seems that harem manga aimed at girls differs from that aimed at boys in three major ways:

There are fewer boys involved, usually 3, instead of a half-dozen or more girls.

There may be some plot beyond “falling in love”, which is why they may not be immediately recognizable as part of this genre or only questionably so. Fruits Basket, for example, has the quest to break a mystical curse. Ouran High School Host Club features cross-dressing. The Wallflower has four guys trying to “reform” a goth horror fan.

And usually, there’s a lot less obvious fan service. Guy characters their for the visuals don’t thrust their crotches or chests at the viewer the way harem girls flash their panties and push out their breasts. Women don’t walk in on men undressing nearly as often as guys do.

So why am I pondering this? Because that’s the whole point of this book. Which of three boys will the orphaned Rui pick? Kaoru? She’s got a crush on him, but he’s fooling around with someone else. Neighbor Taro? They’re such good friends that she crawls into bed with him without a second thought, but she only thinks of him as a friend. Or intern teacher Eisuke? He winds up living with her after another girl burns down his apartment.

I really don’t care for the way Haruka Fukushima’s characters look so very young. It made more sense in her earlier series, Instant Teen, but here, where the focus is romance instead of growing up, it’s creepy. I guess a college student isn’t THAT much older than a junior high girl (although a six-year difference is pretty big at that age), but I still don’t want to see them flirting.

I also find her busy, overdone storytelling horrible. Often, I can’t tell what’s happened. In other cases where the visuals aren’t clear, the writer covers the lack through dialogue or captions, but here, the text is generically boring.

The book is meant to be funny, but instead of laughing, it’s so frantic that I felt nothing but tired after reading it. (A complimentary copy for this review was provided by the publisher.)

3 Comments

  1. [...] [Review] Orange Planet Vol. 1 Link: Johanna Draper Carlson [...]

  2. [...] Beasi on vols. 1 and 2 of Off*Beat (there it is, plain as daylight) Johanna Draper Carlson on vol. 1 of Orange Planet (Comics Worth Reading) Scott Campbell on vol. 22 of Project Arms – The Last Revelation: Return [...]

  3. [...] have five inhabitants — ghosts, all boys. (According to the author, Polterguys is inspired by “reverse harem” shojo manga like Fruits Basket and Ouran High School Host Club, in which a girl is surrounded by lots of cute [...]

Leave a Reply

Comments are closed.