Superman vs. the Elite
June 10, 2012

Superman vs. the Elite, a 74-minute original DC animated movie, opens with Manchester Black (Robin Atkin Downes) watching one of those immense banks of monitors so popular in comics. Since it was reminding him (and thus us, the viewers) about how depressing the world situation was — war, extreme political viewpoints, living in fear — I immediately became concerned that this was NOT the right movie for me to be watching in my currently delicate mental state. (I was laid off three weeks ago, and when I don’t have enough to do, I get twitchy and obsessed in negative ways.)

However, then came the credits, which are done in a blend of 80s neon paste-up stripes and ransom-note-style cut text, layered with Ben-day dots and really old images of Superman. I’m talking 1940s Fleischer cartoons and Curt Swan drawings. It’s as though someone tried to mash up punk band flyers with bright kiddie-safe colors. Weirdly jarring, especially coming after the Ellisian Black, but a good sign that this movie would not be as predictable as I feared it could be.

Superman vs. the Elite was written by Joe Kelly based on his story published as “What’s So Funny About Truth, Justice and the American Way?” in Action Comics #775. The comic is available in the Justice League Elite collection, art by Doug Mahnke with Lee Bermejo.

After the credits, an opening TV cartoon clip really brings home how stodgy Superman is perceived as a character, with an obvious “crime doesn’t pay” message and caricatures of old-fashioned bank robbers. For many people, he is stuck in the 50s, in the Adventures of Superman TV show, and making him relevant is a daunting (but worthwhile) task that I wish more creators would tackle. By having Clark and Lois watch this TV show proposal within the story, Kelly brings the problem to the forefront without being too heavy-handed.

It’s not all that accomplished. I don’t really buy that the UN would hold a hearing asking Superman why he didn’t kill a supervillain. It seems a bit direct; I would expect that discussion to happen in the media, not on the political stage. But it foreshadows what’s going to happen as Superman first befriends the Elite and then comes to disagreement with them over their methods.

Superman vs. the Atomic Skull in Superman vs. the Elite

Since I fondly remember Warren Ellis revitalizing Stormwatch and turning them into The Authority, the Elite (based on the latter) make me laugh, even when they’re trying to be all scary and serious. How can you not giggle at a team with a drunk mystic who dresses like a ska skateboarder? Or a leader who says, “Pam, I’m handing out ultimatums, please keep it in your pants”? Then they start killing terrorists — a timely threat, one with lots of hot buttons — and it all turns very serious.

The Elite from Superman vs. the Elite

There are a lot of meta comments and allusions for the older reader, from the Jay Ward-looking “Superman Adventure” cartoon show using the Super Friends scene change sound effect to seeing editor Perry White fussing at a young Jimmy Olsen (both of whom I’ve missed seeing). Kelly clearly appreciates all the aspects of Superman’s life, even including a scene at the Fortress of Solitude, staffed by working super-robots, and sending Clark home to get advice from his dad.

Perry White and Jimmy Olsen in Superman vs. the Elite

George Newbern, as Superman and Clark Kent, and Pauley Perrette, as Lois, do an excellent job, sounding just like they should. Newbern reminds me of Tim Daly’s readings, which I appreciated, since he’s the classic modern voice for me. As for Lois, I particularly like the hint of roughness in her voice, making it clear this is an accomplished woman who knows what she wants and is a worthy partner for him. She also wisecracks a lot.

Lois and a super-robot in Superman vs. the Elite

I also loved that they’re a couple, and she knows all of his identities. I miss that. I wish we had a lot more of them together conversing and flirting. If I were writing this movie (ha!), we’d have more of that and less of the required action, like the opening fight with the Atomic Skull. That’s not why I watch the cartoons — but I’m know that I’m weird that way. Most of the audience for superhero animation wants to see the superpowers, not the relationships. Still, my favorite part was seeing them together at the office. I like seeing the full scope of their life together, and it reminded me of how much I enjoyed Lois & Clark.

Clark and Lois work together in Superman vs. the Elite

Speaking of animation, the movie looked better on my TV screen than these promo clips made me think it would. The character design is the weakest part of the movie, with simplified figures who can appear flat, but the overall impression once you add in the backgrounds, movement, and special effects was strong and successful. Lois and Clark look like people hanging out together when they’re sitting on their couch watching the news or discussing current events. His shoulders are still square and she’s still curvy, but it’s a pleasure to see them look possible instead of like geometric shapes glued together, as some of the more exaggerated designs had it.

Lois and Clark on the couch in Superman vs. the Elite

I went into Superman vs. the Elite fearing that it would depress me and make me feel left out of the audience (since what I want to watch isn’t what they want to sell me). I came out thinking that this was the best of the original DC animated movies for providing both updated nostalgia and serious themes livened with comedy. This is a story that shows what can be done with Superman to keep him relevant today. By reflecting all the various aspects of his entire life, it’s Superman the way he’s supposed to be. He should be a father figure, someone who does the right thing and inspires us to do so as well. The whole point is that he’s better than us.

Additional Thoughts on Philosophy

I do wish that more emphasis had been placed on how wrong the people were who supported the idea of killing the bad guys without trial, confident in a misplaced certainty. I suppose that might become too political or uncomfortable for the viewers. It’s not just an argument between the superpowered, though, but a loss of the idea of aiming for a better way, even if it hurts and is harder to achieve. The question is really “who do we want making the rules for us?” when we should be making our own rules, but that’s way too hard for us to live up to. Instead, we want to be told what to do, and if that’s the case, we need more role models like Superman, willing to sacrifice to do the right thing, not the expedient or popular one.

Ultimately, since this is a cartoon movie, while Black spouts off on the media a lot, this philosophical debate does boil down to characters slugging each other on the moon. Since the argument is that we wouldn’t want to live in a world where might makes right, since we’re all cowards and hypocrites when the violence turns against us, it’s a mixed message. Especially since Superman has to beat up the bad guys to make them see that violence isn’t the solution. (Such is the innate contradiction of the character.) Here, Superman scares us into seeing the right thing to do, which isn’t the most elegant or advanced answer. A deep reading of the movie emphasizes our childlike moral status. We aren’t willing to deny ourselves in order to reach an ethical outcome.

Special Features

I previously posted the trailer with a list of the Blu-ray disc’s special features, which I will elaborate on here. The creative team audio commentary turns out to be Joe Kelly and Eddie Berganza, editor on the original story.

Superman vs. the Elite character designs

“The Elite Unbound: No Rules, No Mercy” runs 14 minutes, featuring Joe Kelly talking about the creation of the team and characters. I don’t have much to say about it, but I found it interesting, especially in hearing Kelly’s inspirations and influences. Plus, it adds more depth to the team characters who don’t get much background in the film itself.

“Superman and the Moral Debate” is 17 1/2 minutes of talking heads — writer Joe Kelly, exec Mike Carlin, Jaye Razor (credited as actor and military drill instructor), Gregory McNeal (law professor), and Miguel Unzueta (social psychologist) — debating justice in our world and perceptions of our legal system. (Apparently no women have opinions on Superman and societal fairness.) McNeal at one point uses the phrase “courageous restraint”, which I really liked. The core debate is whether Superman’s value system is relevant in a post-9/11 world.

The Batman: The Dark Knight Returns, Part 1 sneak peek runs 12 1/2 minutes, showing design sketches and original Frank Miller comic images. It’s early days yet, but if they keep the color treatment they show in the preliminary art, without black lines, this will look impressive, distinctive yet updated. Commentary comes from producers Bruce Timm and Alan Burnett, writer Bob Goodman, my favorite voice director Andrea Romano, and director Jay Oliva (who reveals he was 10 when the original came out, the baby). Plus, we see the voice talent starting their work. (Random thought: Since the bad guys are the Mutants, I want to see a fan mash-up where the bad guys are replaced with footage from the X-Men movies.)

The sneak peeks at All-Star Superman and Superman/Batman: Public Enemies are similar, but for the previously released movies. As expected, the promised digital comic copy of Action Comics #775 turns out to be a few pages with a link to DC’s webstore. The Dark Knight Rises photo gallery is just over a dozen images already released.

There’s also a single-disc DVD edition of Superman vs. the Elite, which only includes the promotions for Dark Knight Returns, Dark Knight Rises, All-Star Superman, and Superman/Batman: Public Enemies. The two-disc DVD special edition will be released in late July.

As usual, I found the opening previews enlightening when it comes to seeing who the studio thinks the audience is. First was a trailer for the first season of My Babysitter’s a Vampire. More and more, I realize that there are TV shows I’ve never even heard of out there, and many of them are aimed at kids. This is one of them.

Next came two minutes of actors (I assume, since they seem too well-spoken to be real kids on the street) talking about being needed as promo for the We Can Be Heroes effort, where you can “join the Justice League to fight the hunger crisis” in Darfur. I’m bitter and jaded, I know, but all I could think was that if Time Warner gave a percentage of its profits instead of trying to entice its customers to donate, the crisis would be a lot further towards being solved. However, if that doesn’t bother you, then the trailer is a good choice for a movie about responsibility and morality. (The studio provided a review copy.)

10 Responses  
Anthony writes:  

I’ve seen the “heroes should kill their villains” argument turn up a lot in online remarks, including as a criticism of Superman (“he’s too wimpy for not being willing to kill”), as well as a constant “Batman should kill the Joker!” outcry. Never mind the latter seems to assume a pro-death penalty stance, or that the people argue “even anti-death penalty people would argue that the Joker should be killed!” (which I don’t; other than the usual reasons I have against it, in real life, mass murderers don’t repeatedly escape from prison to slaughter more people than a WWII battle), or ignore that the Joker’s problem is being written into a corner (if he doesn’t do anything other than WWII-level mass slaughter/engage in adolescent shock-value violence, why should I care about him as a character? Which I don’t—enough I’m not interested in seeing “The Dark Knight”—but anyway…).

On a frivolous note: Is Lois’ hair brown in this movie? Thought we’d (finally) moved back to her hair being permanently black again (after her brown hair in late 80s and 90s comics)…

James Schee writes:  

Huh my local Wal-Mart has made the mistake of putting this out this weekend, when it isn’t due until Tuesday. I had started to get it but held off, as I wondered at quality, since the DC Animated movies have either been classics, or train wrecks.

I wish I’d gotten it now, as I am on a Lois & Clark splurge right now. Spurred by The Hub network running the L&C show on Sunday nights now. It just reminds me why I used to love the Superma mythos, and everything that is missing from it currently.

For me superheroes don’t kill because then they become no better than who they fight. Though I do think at times writers have gone to insane lengths to keep bad guys alive, when due to their own hubris their comeuppance should have come from themselves.

I’ll have to check this out see how it plays.

Oh and, uhm I was only 10 when Batman TDKR came out as well.:) Thanks for making me feel better, as I felt really old talking with a creator on Twitter who said that Saved By The Bell was before their time. lol

Johanna writes:  

Yes, Lois’ hair is brown, which seems more realistic to me. Aside from believing that superheroes shouldn’t kill, I also believe that we shouldn’t have death of any kind in superhero comics, because it’s pointless. No one believes it any more anyway. Good point about the Joker, too, Anthony — he’s become only one of his traits, and not even the most interesting one.

James, I agree about being reminded what we’re missing.

Thad writes:  

Sorry to hear about the layoff — it’s rough all over. (I’ve been working as a temp for the past three and a half years — and if you want an indication of how much of my adult life that is, I was three when Dark Knight Returns came out — and while it looks like I’ll have work through November, what happens after that is anybody’s guess. Hate the feeling that the axe could fall at any minute.)

Anyhow, sounds like fun. I loved The Authority but never got around to reading What’s So Funny?, and I think, like Watchmen and DKR before it, Authority has been imitated by a whole bunch of people who don’t understand what it was that made it special in the first place — people who are attracted to the “mature” violence and angst but not the actually-mature themes and questions underpinning them.

James Schee writes:  

Just watched it, and dang this so reminds me why Lois is such a dynamic character. And it was so good to see a Superman who stood for something, without feeling like he was a walking PSA.

I do question some of what Superman does to the Elite, but a very enjoyable movie.

Thad writes:  

…come to think of it, Timm’s played with the Superman-versus-Authority premise before. There was an episode of Justice League (wouldn’t be surprised if it was on the “Special Edition” of this, though I think they may have packed it in with Crisis or somesuch) where they fought their parallel-universe equivalents, the Justice Lords, who used lethal force (and whose Superman lobotomized criminals with his heat vision — the most memorable scene is a walk through Arkham where every Batman villain has two burn marks on his forehead — even the dummy). The resemblance to the Authority would have been pretty obvious even if Timm HADN’T explicitly cited them as an influence.

Indeed, it set off an entire three-season arc building on Superman’s fear — and everyone else’s — that he would follow down the same path as his counterpart.

(Spoiler alert: he didn’t.)

Johanna writes:  

Thanks, Thad, and I’m sorry to hear you’re in a similar place. (And entertainment conglomerates wonder why we’re all so reluctant to spend money and looking for free-even-if-not-legal options. ) I don’t recall the details of the comic source myself, but I suspect this may be a better presentation, with the just-over-an-hour length allowing for a bit more space.

Speed Reading: Reviews « Speed Force writes:  

[…] Superman vs. the Elite at DVDs Worth Watching […]

Batman: The Dark Knight Returns, Part 1 (Blu-ray Review) » DVDs Worth Watching writes:  

[…] Sneak Peek at Superman/Batman: Public Enemies — 8 minutes, and I think this previously appeared on Superman vs. the Elite […]

Batman: The Dark Knight Returns Part 2 » DVDs Worth Watching writes:  

[…] a 12-minute promo for Batman: The Dark Knight Returns, Part 1 that was previously released on the Superman vs. the Elite movie and an ad for the DC kids’ cartoons on DVD. (The studio provided a review […]


»  Substance: WordPress   »  Style: Ahren Ahimsa
Copyright 2009-2015 Johanna Draper Carlson