*Smile — Best of 2010

Raina Telgemeier, previously known for her excellent work adapting the The Baby-Sitters Club into four graphic novels, here tells her own teen story, one of much dental trauma.

Smile cover
Buy this book
Also available in hardcover

One night, sixth-grader Raina trips and falls at a Girl Scout meeting. She hits the ground, is shaken for a moment, but sits up thinking everything’s ok … until she sees blood on the ground. Her front teeth are gone.

(A personal note: about the same age, I had a similar, although less serious, accident, and it happened exactly that way. I fell on a tile floor, and both my front teeth were cracked off. Only I didn’t know what had happened until my mother saw me and was shocked. I was lucky — mine could be rebuilt, and no nerves were exposed. The reconstruction technique used on p174 was what was done for me.)

Now, at a time when she’s dealing with all kinds of other changes — friends, school, boys — Raina has to put up with headgear, surgeries, and other scary techniques in an attempt to restore her smile. The kids are just beginning to worry about how they appear to other people, but they’re still young enough to ask her all kinds of prying questions without thought of how she might feel about all this unwelcome attention.

The artist Raina shows all this without shying away from the frightening events, but her cartoony style is also welcoming to younger readers. It allows her to exaggerate slightly for emotional impact — it’s always obvious what her characters are feeling — and it keeps everything from being too scary. When things get too much, the reader can always flip to the back of the book, where the author’s photo shows us her now-beautiful smile, reminding us that everything turned out ok, eventually.

In the story, though, she’s got an external reminder of feeling like a kid, with her now-childish gapped smile. Unfortunately, that’s at a time when she’s facing lots of other choices about trying to seem more grown up. She wants to get her ears pierced. She has to get braces. All of her friends are approaching adolescence at different rates of speed, and sometimes she feels left behind. Being 12 is a real turning point in life, and the best part of the book is the way teenage Raina learns to make her own choices.

As she prepares for high school, Raina has her first crush and finds out what she wants to do when she grows up. She also learns how to tell real friends from those who simply hang out with you because it’s convenient. I like the way this story, because it’s autobiographical, doesn’t progress in a neat arc — instead, there are false starts and changes in direction. Raina’s a sympathetic heroine, more interested in doing things than worrying about her appearance, which takes her in a different direction from some of her friends. Her external changes mirror her internal coming-of-age.

Raina has posted preview pages at her website, or there’s a video trailer. Here’s an extra single-page comic. The publisher provided a review copy.

16 Responses to “*Smile — Best of 2010”

  1. ~chris Says:

    “Raina’s a sympathetic heroine, more interested in doing things than worrying about her appearance”

    I also liked that Raina is not a perfect heroine (in her book) who does the right thing every time.

  2. david brothers Says:

    I thought this was a fantastic read, and I’ve also got a “fell flat on my face and knocked out a couple teeth” story. I was in 1st grade, though, and it happened during a break in class.

    But yeah, Smile! I’m very happy to have read it.

  3. Johanna Says:

    I’ve been surprised how many people have similar stories. And Chris, that’s the benefit of authentic autobiography, seeing the mistakes as well as the lessons.

  4. Rob McMonigal Says:

    I also liked Smile, and given our similar ages, a lot of references to culture fit perfectly for me.

    I have yet to see someone dislike Smile. I have a funny feeling it’s going to make a lot of “Best of 2010″ lists.

  5. Kat Kan Says:

    And the kids in my school love it! I think almost everyone in the 3rd grade class read it, and it outsold all other books in my Scholastic Book Fair in February.

  6. Johanna Says:

    Rob, let’s hope — although I think such a down-to-earth, homey story may not get the notice it deserves. It’s not flashy, which works against getting award attention.

    Kat, so glad to hear it! Love to see kids enjoying great comics.

  7. SPX 2010 Coming Fast! Plus Intervention » Comics Worth Reading Says:

    […] this a darling promotional poster by Raina Telgemeier (Smile)? Look at all those diverse people enjoying comics and the chocolate fountain that’s a […]

  8. Best Graphic Novels of 2010 » Comics Worth Reading Says:

    […] Smile by Raina Telgemeier — Adolescence as symbolized by dental trauma in an easy-to-read story approachable by all ages. […]

  9. EMMA Says:

    this comic is the first comic book i read it a fantastic book and i would love it have a second book recommed it totally

  10. January 2012 Previews: Recommendations, Reminders, and Ramblings » Comics Worth Reading Says:

    […] another of my 2011 Best Graphic Novels, Anya’s Ghost. Additional relists this month include Smile (Graphix, JAN12 1143, $10.99, March 21), Magic Trixie (Harper Collins, JAN12 1145, $8.99, March […]

  11. Drama Cover Revealed; Telgemeier’s Followup to Smile » Comics Worth Reading Says:

    […] Telgemeier (author of Smile, one of the best graphic novels of 2010) has released this cover to her next book, Drama. Due in […]

  12. TCAF Teen Boat Comic Features Wonderful Cameos » Comics Worth Reading Says:

    […] recognize Babymouse and that guinea pig PI, plus characters by Raina Telgemeier (Smile) and Faith Erin Hicks (with her ghost) and Vera Brosgol (with her ghost), an Astronaut Academy kid […]

  13. *Drama — Best of 2012 » Comics Worth Reading Says:

    […] Telgemeier’s Smile, about her adolescence, was one of my best graphic novels of 2010. Now, as she moves into fiction, […]

  14. Raina Telgemeier Announces Next Book, Sisters » Comics Worth Reading Says:

    […] Telgemeier has announced her next book, Sisters. It’s billed as a companion to 2010′s Smile, her autobiographical story about growing up with dental work. Sisters, portraying Raina’s […]

  15. Sisters Cover Revealed, Makes Smile Connection Obvious » Comics Worth Reading Says:

    […] face on the left resembles the cover to her blockbuster autobiographical comic Smile, a frequent inhabitant of the New York Times bestseller list, making the connection between the two […]

  16. *Sisters — Recommended » Comics Worth Reading Says:

    […] the immense success of the best-selling, Eisner Award-winning Smile, it’s no surprise that Raina Telgemeier has created another graphic memoir. Sisters takes a […]




Most Recent Posts: